Its rivalry with saudi arabia would have been fairly unspectacular and certainly not a subject for such a book, if not for something unique that occurred in iran during 1979. There are many vast and wide implications of a cold war in the middle east and it is central to address how accurate a description this cold war framework is when analyzing the saudi arabian and iranian relationship. Nov 12, 2017 should escalating tensions between bitter regional rivals iran and saudi arabia break out into open conflict, riyadhs formidable military arsenal would quickly overwhelm iranian forces in a. Nov 22, 2017 if there was a conflict between saudi arabia and iran, however, thaker said it would be the most dangerous times for the middle east and the world. To understand the current conflict, it is important to understand that the history of the middle east is not one of widespread and perpetual wars and conflicts between the two sects. Why saudi arabia and iran are bitter rivals bbc news. The iransaudi arabia proxy conflict, sometimes also referred to as the iransaudi arabia cold war, middle east cold war or middle east conflict, is the ongoing struggle for influence in the middle east and surrounding regions between the islamic republic of iran and the kingdom of saudi arabia. Iran and saudi arabia, on the two sides of the sunnishiite fault line, are trying to gain influence in reshaping the middle east. The enmity between iran and saudi arabia is a persistent feature of middle eastern geopolitics. How the iraniansaudi proxy struggle tore apart the middle. The yemen card is a strategic bargaining chip that iran may now be holding visavis the sudden rise of the houthis.
Cnni talks to robert danin of the council on foreign relations about the wider implications of the escalating rift between saudi arabia and iran. Prospect of usiran conflict threatens gulf economies. Saudi arabia has made clear that it sees the conflict in yemen as the extension of its struggle with the islamic republic. Saudi arabias involvement clearly lies in its interest in keeping the yemeni allied government in power for these reasons while iran saw the weak state as an opportunity to gain advantage over saudi arabia in yet another conflict and used its shia ties to the revolutionaries to gain access.
The two countries have provided varying degrees of support to opposing sides in nearby conflicts, including the civil wars in syria, yemen, and iraq. Occasional paper understanding irans role in the syrian. It has many levels but at its root it is our ideology contra their realpolitik. The nature of the saudiiranian rivalry has led many middle east experts to identify their rivalry as a new middle east cold war. Saudi arabia and iran s rivalry is key to the middle east in 2018 regional chaos is set to continue with no solution in sight to yemen crisis and power struggle over shape of post war. State failure happens when the basic functions of the state provision of security, infrastructure, the rule of law, etc. Introduction for this study the researcher will examine both the iranian and saudi arabian options of being a superior power in the middle east and the conflict this race to the top.
The iran saudi arabia proxy conflict, sometimes also referred to as the middle eastern cold war is the ongoing struggle for influence in the middle east and surrounding regions between the islamic republic of iran and the kingdom of saudi arabia. In this episode, arunank discusses about this issue by explaining the history of the conflict and relations of the two countries and the major reason behind the issue nuclear weapons. One map that explains the dangerous saudiiranian conflict. Dec 23, 2017 the ongoing conflict, widely seen as a proxy war between saudi arabia and iran, could become even more volatile in the wake of a missile fired at riyadh earlier this week. Contacts are carried out through the iranian interests section of the pakistani embassy in washington, d. Managing the saudiiran rivalry council on foreign relations.
Introduction as halliday 2005 well said, the task of. Now we can calculate the payoffs of sanction and war for the us separately as shown below. Tensions between saudi arabia and iran council on foreign. Saudi arabia, sudan and bahrain sever diplomatic ties with iran, and the uae downgrades its relations with the islamic republic. Nov 10, 2017 the united states military says the missile targeting the saudis has iranian markings. The kingdom of saudi arabia, occupies the majority of the arabian peninsula. War as a form of conflict often destroy the lives and properties of countless individuals. Saudi arabia, iran and the great game in yemen iran. Jul 17, 2017 but underneath all the conflict, there are two common actors. The enmity between iran and saudi arabia exploded last weekend, after the saudi execution of a prominent shia cleric along with dozens of other citizens accused of terrorism. King saud visits iran, and the shah reciprocates two. Fulan nasrullah is the executive director of the conflict studies and analysis project at the global initiative for civil stabilisation. One workshop participant explained that the principal sources of.
Theniranian president khatami met saleh by this point, president of a unified yemen in 2003, and managed to reach an accord, which later deteriorated after the beginning of the houthi insurgency in 2004. The following is a timeline of iran saudi relations since the 1979 revolution. After the death of the prophet muhammad, his followers split. How the saudiiran conflict might align with prophecy.
Jan 05, 2016 tensions in the middle east typically drive up oil prices but the saudia arabia iran conflict will further depress prices, says stephen myrow. Saudi arabia and the gulf states have been fighting an ongoing proxy war with iran in yemen,iraq, lebanon and syria. The financial times and its journalism are subject to a selfregulation regime under the ft editorial code of practice. The usa should make a conjecture about iran playing defiance or war and then on this basis needs to compare the payoffs of the sanction or war.
Saudi arabia remains publicly neutral, but reportedly makes three of its. The chain of events that has started with the execution of shiite scholar sheikh nimr alnimrs death sentence by saudi arabia on january 2, 2016 together with 46 people and continued with setting the saudi arabias consulate in mashhad and embassy. Explaining the longterm hostility between the united states and iran. Iran has just, through negotiations, gotten so far that it was invited in these major talks that were seeing every couple months on saudi arabia. The rivalry explained the enmity between iran and saudi arabia is a persistent feature of middle eastern geopolitics. Although ideology has played a role, their respective regional strategic interests have largely shaped their relationship.
The breach in diplomatic relations between iran and saudi arabia is a dangerous watershed in an already unstable, war torn region. The ongoing conflict, widely seen as a proxy war between saudi arabia and iran, could become even more volatile in the wake of a missile fired at riyadh earlier this week. The rupture has its roots in a strategic rivalry that stretches across the middle east, says bernard haykel, middle east expert at princeton university. Dec 20, 2017 the conflict between iran and saudi arabia is fueling some of the regions most intractable conflicts. Pdf conflicts between iran and the gulf arab states. Behind the iransaudi arabia conflict liberation news. This paper is also downloadable in pdf format from the bottom of the page. Members of iran s islamic revolutionary guard corp irgc march during a military parade to commemorate the 198088 iran iraq war in tehran, iran on september 22, 2007. The gulf cooperation council was created as a response to iran s islamic revolution, which stirred unrest across the middle east, particularly among the regions shiite population. It began with tentative decisionmaking during the iran iraq war in 1980, but shifted to a more proactive stance as the cold war started to thaw in 1987, when the council adopted a settlement plan, which iraq and iran accepted in 1988, bringing active hostilities to an end. However, in terms of the number of participants, the. Iran has a large population and a long history of nationhood, while saudi arabia holds significant oil reserves and is custodian of islams holiest sites before the 1979 iranian revolution, relations between iran and saudi arabia proceeded without major incident. Whats behind the feud between saudi arabia and iran. Cyber warfare is an increasingly prominent aspect of the iraniansaudi hegemonic rivalry in the middle east.
View saudi arabia and iran conflict a realistic view emelyn peralta 106862028. The conflict between saudi arabia and iran, while historical and religious in origin, has evolved into a geopolitical competition. Saudi arabia, a majority sunni muslim country and iran, a majority shia muslim country, have been in major geopolitical conflict which has intensified since the iranian revolution in 2011 and irans support for syria during the syrian civil war. For iastoppers mains articles archive, click here introduction. It argues that the relationship between the kingdom of saudi arabia and the islamic. In response, iranian protesters stormed the saudi embassy in tehran, and saudi arabia has cut off diplomatic relations with its rival across the persian gulf. An economic evaluation article pdf available in strategic analysis 364.
Regional impact of saudiiranian conflict cnn video. Iran tensions are the 2018 trump administration withdrawal from the 2015. Iran and saudi arabia on the brink of a proxy war over lebanon. The saudis exit the conflict with israel the crown princes recognition of jewish rights is a direct signal to the palestinians and iran, not israel. The cold war between saudi arabia and iran thats tearing apart the middle east, explained the supposedly ancient sunnishia divide is in fact very modern and its not really about religion. The conflict is between saudi arabia, representing sunni islam via wahhabism, and iran, representing shiite islam through khomeinism. Saudi arabia and the regionalization of yemens conflict. Analyzing yemens transition from a fragile to a failed state adds another dimension to understanding yemens conflict that expands beyond the saudi versus iran proxy war narrative. Nov 21, 2017 iran and saudi arabia on the brink of a proxy war over lebanon. A brief breakdown of the current saudi vs iran conflict. Conflict does a lot of psychological and moral damage also.
Suppose that the probability of defiance by iran against the us is q. In spite of us and european assistance, the iranian hegemony has been increasing over the arabian interests in these proxy wars, keeping bashir assad in power, staving off the isis caliphate, and proving arabs impotent to prevail. Jan 06, 2016 one map that explains the dangerous saudi iranian conflict. They are the best weapons we have to insure that truth triumphs over fiction. The escalating proxy war between the majoritysunni muslim kingdom of saudi arabia and iran, the home of shiite islam, is having repercussions across the middle east.
The security dilemma in saudiiranian relations mohamed bin. Kharg island provides a sea port for the export of oil and extends iranian territorial sea claims into the persian gulf oil fields. The security dilemma in saudiiranian relations mohamed. In relation to the iransaudi arabia conflict, however, the oic openly backed riyadh, which deepened intersectarian rifts within the oic. The tensions between saudi arabia and iran go back many.
The islamic revolution in iran led to a dramatic change in the countrys foreign policy outlook and in its involvement in the international arena. In the first, assads government, bolstered by vital aid from iran and russia, controls most of the country and its key population centers in western syria. The breach in diplomatic relations between iran and saudi arabia is a dangerous watershed in an already unstable, wartorn region. It attempts to use the concept of security dilemma to explain the current saudiiranian relations. Theniranian president khatami met saleh by this point, president of a unified yemen in 2003, and managed to reach an accord, which later deteriorated after the. A view from iran on heightened conflict with saudi arabia. Saudi arabia and iran are not only competing for power because of their sectarian differences. Bard october 2011 vi preface john adams, argument in defense of the soldiers in boston massacre trial, december 1770.
Saudiiranian tensions economic effects and political. Iran, on the other hand, is a majority shiite country, with 810 percent of its 80 million population being sunni. The next one is about the take place on january 25. Gradually, however, the new regime was forced to adapt its dogma to reality, and became increasingly pragmatic. This leads, once again, to a ban on iranian pil grims until 1948. Iran has a large population and a long history of nationhood, while saudi arabia holds significant oil reserves and is custodian of islams holiest sites.
In a number of respects, the current internal conflict in iran should be the source of much concern to the leaders of the islamic regime. In the past 15 years in particular, the differences between saudi arabia and iran have been sharpened by a series of events. Pakistan serves as iran s protecting power in the united states, while switzerland serves as the united states protecting power in iran. Pdf what is really behind the saudiiranian cold war. As a result, saudi arabia severed diplomatic ties with iran. Proxy war between iran and saudi arabia intensifies youtube. The move prompts protests or condemnation from shiites in iran, iraq, bahrain, turkey, pakistan, india, lebanon, and yemen. Iran and saudi arabias great rivalry explained bbc news.
Saudi arabia and iran s ongoing battle for power and influence rages on in the middle east but analysts arent convinced that an allout war will happen, yet. Iran, saudi arabia war readiness compared washington times. Iran and the united states have had many formal diplomatic relations since 1980. Us iran relations iranian issue and conflict explained. The organization of islamic cooperation oicwhich represents the entirety of the muslim worldhas traditionally observed a strict policy of neutrality, preferring to resort to closeddoor diplomacy regarding disagreements among its member states. Jan 04, 2016 cnni talks to robert danin of the council on foreign relations about the wider implications of the escalating rift between saudi arabia and iran. Assessing the potential impacts of a usiran war on. In iran, protestors burn part of the saudi embassy in tehran and storm the compound.
Republic of iran has been driven by the existence of a security dilemma. In the hopes of deconstructing the popular but reductionist sunni vs. Our ideology rejects monarchy and alliance with the nonmuslim governmentsnations that are oppressive or impose their will, policies or culture on usmuslims. The escalating proxy war between the majoritysunni muslim kingdom of saudi arabia and iran, the home of shiite islam, is having repercussions across the. Jan 04, 2018 saudi arabia and iran s rivalry is key to the middle east in 2018 regional chaos is set to continue with no solution in sight to yemen crisis and power struggle over shape of postwar syria kareem.
Jan 28, 2016 so iran andiran and russiairan and saudi arabia are competing, say, on syria. Saudi arabia and iran conflict a realistic view emelyn. The russians have intervened on the same sideon the side of the assad government, which is also irans client. How can the growing regional rivalry between iran and saudi arabia and their. They are bitter rivals, whose feud goes back almost 40 years. The iransaudi arabia conflict and its impact on the. Escalation in the conflict between iran and saudi arabia. Nov 10, 2017 the us is deliberately fuelling the conflict between saudi arabia and iran, daily sabah argues. Usiran conflict explained mains article iastoppers. This paper argues that conflict between saudi arabia and iran does reflect their divergent religious beliefs, but above all, it is a case of converging power struggles and strategic geopolitical interests. Policy congressional research service 2 since may 2019, the administration has ended five out of the seven waivers under the iran freedom and counterproliferation act ifca, p. It spoils the mental peace of man which can result in stress related illness. A security dilemma exists in the two states relations as both of them are seeking policies of increasing their relative gains in order to make them secure. Nov 20, 2016 the conflicts toll exhausted irans zeal for sowing revolution abroad, but gave it a new mission.
Demonstrations and riots erupt in iran every few years, protesting primarily intervention by the regime in the life of the individual or the economic situation. Saudiiranian tensions economic effects and political consequences iranian oil workers on kharg island in the persian gulf, february 2016. Iran and saudi arabia are on opposing sides of a more than 1,000year old argument at the heart of islam between sunnis and shia. Assessment paper first published may 2019 assessing the impacts of a potential us iran war on nigeria note. One major area in which iran s policy has remained excessively uncompromising has been the inherent hostility to israel, rejection of. Iran and israel steven simon israel and iran have interacted since israels birth in 1948.
952 1138 1572 503 1122 1120 497 30 13 1573 702 1475 533 1409 432 1288 781 1131 962 493 261 196 1138 240 838 584 1033 319 855 428 545 1224 220 887 1161 519 464